|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 8:41:40 GMT -5
Post by Miles to Go on Jan 25, 2012 8:41:40 GMT -5
Also, newsflash: There IS a third faction (at least), which was brushed off in day 1. Team Skull does exist in this game. Have fun with that. I'm taking this with a grain of salt until one of them actually shows up. MtG shouts something very seemingly random. CtN responds equally random. MtG responds just as random. I am very disappointed in you.So apparently Mountain has just given up, but since apparently no one else is interested in lynching him, I'll begrudgingly ##Unvote: Mountain. I'm tempted to put a vote on Crashing Down, his wall of text didn't impress me, and he's confusing me again by saying Mountain was the scummiest and then voting for Fisherman's Boy instead. It's possible that FB's case was a last ditch attempt to save Tarnished Silver though. ... ##Vote: Crashing Down
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 8:47:51 GMT -5
Post by Crashing Down on Jan 25, 2012 8:47:51 GMT -5
MtG shouts something very seemingly random. CtN responds equally random. MtG responds just as random. I am very disappointed in you.So apparently Mountain has just given up, but since apparently no one else is interested in lynching him, I'll begrudgingly ##Unvote: Mountain. I'm tempted to put a vote on Crashing Down, his wall of text didn't impress me, and he's confusing me again by saying Mountain was the scummiest and then voting for Fisherman's Boy instead. It's possible that FB's case was a last ditch attempt to save Tarnished Silver though. ... ##Vote: Crashing Down[/quote] I had been rereading at the time to summarize, and found FB scummier then. When I mentioned Mountain, it was before the summarizing began. Can't finish summarizing quite yet, I have some IRL errands that need done. Be back in around 3 hours.
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 10:21:18 GMT -5
Post by Fisherman's Boy on Jan 25, 2012 10:21:18 GMT -5
FoS in Crashing Down's direction for sheeping, pseudo-contributing, and her vote on me which I wouldn't mind so much if it weren't so weak and vague.
Next thing I post will be proper analysis and less of the useless bullshit I've posted so far.
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 10:51:27 GMT -5
Post by May Queen on Jan 25, 2012 10:51:27 GMT -5
Ok, so exile STILL hasn't said enything and considering he hasn't been on since the 18th I don't think that'll change soon. That said, my original plan of pressuring him if he doesn't defend himself isn't going to work.
Also, I can only really get on here once a day regardless, and you guys are never here at the times I am, so contributing is hard, especially when my thoughts are generally said by other people and sure. Sorry ToT.
Thinking MtG is townish, as a lot of what he says makes sense and he seems to be trying to help. And as exile won't respond to the well made argument against him, I'll go for the next best guy, who I'm thinking as Crashing down at the moment. I think that summary was a forced way of trying to gain the town's favour, when summaries both help the town and the scum.
##Vote: Crashing down
I much prefer an exile lynch, but after the strange things CD has said, I'm willing to participate in this lynch.
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 10:56:07 GMT -5
Post by Fisherman's Boy on Jan 25, 2012 10:56:07 GMT -5
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 11:06:15 GMT -5
Post by Crashing Down on Jan 25, 2012 11:06:15 GMT -5
Night Summary time. Page 1: clipsey starts. Mountain states stuff as a reply to MtG. Next important post is after some discussion between Mountain and clipsey. Inspiration is quite helpful with more summary of the day. MQ is helpful. Inspiration tiers the people. Sedna Also makes a nice list. I continue my trend of posting when I feel there is a need. WBB answers ToT at last. Exile makes a post referencing posts in D1. Clipsey does more help than anyone in the phase. Oh, fuck you, Sedna. Another town Persuader. KS is wary of this, and interrogates WBB. I answer about the substitutes, and am also wary of Sedna. Page 2: Mountain is wary about MtG's reason to not unvote. Miles, I can't summarize this! Scroll down to read the last pieces of MtG's discussion. Mountain retorts. MQ agrees with MtG about Sedna persuading. MtG doesn't like Mountain. Stop being so random, Mountain and Miles. Sedna will persuade someone. ToT does a very odd answer to MtG. MtG wasn't attacking ToT. Page 3: ToT does some stuff, including the Night Bomb statement. KS questions. FB also questions ToT. ToT replies about stuff. I throw a possibility. Sedna asks ToT to tone down the sarcasm. ToT agrees to it while still being sarcastic. KS asks Kay to lock the topic.
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 11:10:44 GMT -5
Post by Kay on Jan 25, 2012 11:10:44 GMT -5
Crashing Down, just pointing out that you've technically voted for yourself. Watch the quote tags.
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 11:18:10 GMT -5
Post by Crashing Down on Jan 25, 2012 11:18:10 GMT -5
Day 2 Time! Page 1: Kay opens up. Mafia makes us all lol by killing Stone Soup, who... isn't a player. So far, so good. ToT immediately votes Exile. KS thinks ToT might be third party. MtG votes Mountain. I have a life, you see. ToT does not claim third party. I make a post I meant to be more informative, but ToT's explanation for it all was better than what I would have come up with. KS doesn't like sheeping. I think I know who KS is, and then ask questions. MQ asks if I admit to trying to appease ToT. (Simple answer: No.) I answer MQ, with an admittedly confusing explanation. MtG thinks I'm confusing. Sedna persuaded WBB to vote me. Page 2: Sedna then votes WBB. WBB votes me with a lot of explanation which I have yet to retort, expect that in 2 more of my posts. Team Skull is here? Exile finally answers us. Summary, part 1.1 ToT makes a very helpful post. Summary, part 1.2 I reply, including an explanation of how I post if I find a reason to post. I vote FB before bed. Votals, clipse finally gets an avvie, KS wonders where everyone is, and clipse reiterates the fact. WBB is informed. Sedna unvotes. Page 3: MtG votes me for being more of me. I retort MtG. MQ votes me but wants an Exile lynch. FB summarizes person by person. Night 1 Summary OH SHIT, WHAT? STUPID FUCKING QUOTE TAGS. ##Unvote: Fisherman's Boy (and Crashing Down)
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 11:44:09 GMT -5
Post by Crashing Down on Jan 25, 2012 11:44:09 GMT -5
OK, my actual first post is things I've gleaned from each person based on what I have seen
Call the Names: Needs to exist again. Come back. And plenty of BS to get at you for. Crashing Down: Confusing, yes. Scummylooking, possible. People overreact, yes. Claiming, possibly. Exile: Where the fuck are you? FB: Plenty of bullshit in Day 1, almost nonexistant in Night 1, starting to make sense Day 2. Inspiration: Why did you disappear? This game is difficult without people talking. Kingsword: You are one of those who I think I know who you are. May Queen: Has brought up good points. One of those I feel is town. Measure of a Man: Exist, dammit. Miles to Go: Excellently doing his job of being town and making arguments. Mountain: The scummiest, upon reading. Disappearing when beaten is a scumtell to me. Sedna: Wary about Town Persuader claim, but decent nonetheless. Trail of Tears: The protownest. Good arguments and encouraging others to speak. War Between Brothers: Has made a grand 1 decent argument, and it was on his persuaded vote.
Yeah, Mountain, I don't like the look of you.
He kept up a very weak argument against Miles, and has vanished off the map upon being defeaten.
I'd prefer a Mountain Lynch to an Exile Lynch, as Exile has at least been on more recently. And May, due to the invisibility powers, none of us have been on since the 18th.
So for now, ##Vote: Mountain
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 13:19:58 GMT -5
Post by Crashing Down on Jan 25, 2012 13:19:58 GMT -5
I am thinking about it, I've just taken a while to pull all my notes together. So, the following: ##Vote: Crashing DownLet's begin. Crashing Down (henceforth known as CD) didn't contribute ANYTHING at all in the first day, no vote, barely any game discussion, nothing. Call it slightly hypocritical if you want, but at least I attempted some sort of weird logic-y position. I know I wasn't particularly helpful. Let's look at this post from Day 1 (#35): She said we needed results. But did she even vote? No. This was her last response in day 1. She offers the following as a alibi for not much activity (#6, Day 2): [qupte]Yes, that's nice and all, and I can see why not much happened, and there wasn't much need for input, it's still a bit too suss. ToT called her out on her inactivity in day 2 (#7): Seriously, this pretty much nails it on the head. To get other people to vote and actually have discussion while not contributing much yourself, possibly to try to slip under the radar and not get yourself lynched seems like the most logical explanation for these actions. It gets better. Looking at: (#8 Day 2) I have no vote yet. I haven't really got a firm opinion on anyone. If I must vote before I can tell them to come, then I will ##Vote: ExileTrail puts up a good point. Why were you trying to defend Silver? I'm getting myself almost killed by not having an opinion on people. It's just not good enough if you want to survive and actually make meaningful contributions. I'm starting to form well informed opinions on people so that I can actually vote properly. Kingsword immediately calls out CD for being a sheep (#9), and CD responds with not actually that much to defend (#10, #12) Like Miles said, it's really confusing. CD doesn't actually put forward any defense that makes that much sense. In closing: CD has called multiple times for more action, but yet doesn't actually contribute much to the discussion at all. By not having a meaningful presence, she looks very suspicious. (I will add more later if more stuff comes up.) (I now have an avvy, to appease the masses.) Let me poke at this for a bit. Like I have said several times, I only post if something is worth posting. While I didn't really do much Day 1, I didn't see you doing any more than throwing a flimsy argument against Trail, which you never returned to reply back to her after she retorted you. Seems scummy to just drop an argument for no reason. And I am starting to form opinions as well. I went and made that summary so I could easily reread the day. It was more for my help than to help you, but I shared it so others can read it. When I voted Exile, I admit to sheeping, but I wanted info. Info can lead to results, and you guys all know how I like results. So with that said, I am wanting to either see Mountain return or see his neck stuck in the hangman's noose today.
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 13:21:04 GMT -5
Post by Crashing Down on Jan 25, 2012 13:21:04 GMT -5
And yes, that was a contradiction of what I said in the summary. I was sheeping in technicality, but the reasons were for information. One vote doesn't usually bring in the info.
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 15:15:15 GMT -5
Post by Inspiration on Jan 25, 2012 15:15:15 GMT -5
Sorry guys, I tend to be less active on school nights; I'm a little too concerned about grades.
So much for an anonymous, game, it's so obvious who subbed in for who - and who is who. C'mon guys, be more discreet.
Anyways, I'm guessing that Mountain hasn't been responding because he got subbed out (...it's a little obvious who he was), as well as Crashing Down's change in logic (uh...yeah, I know you're calling out people for not being active, but [your, and others] bad logic ain't going to help either).
I saw some, as ToT puts it, OMGUS posts, but lots of clashes in logic; give me an hour or two to read through / get home (I'm actually at school, hee). Phase ends in like 12 hours, sooo, yeah, I'll get on that.
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 15:25:03 GMT -5
Post by Trail of Tears on Jan 25, 2012 15:25:03 GMT -5
Anyways, I'm guessing that Mountain hasn't been responding because he got subbed out (...it's a little obvious who he was) It's arguably more obvious who he is now that he isn't posting. May, why is CD worth voting over Exile just because Exile won't respond? If anything, that makes Exile lurkscum, which is why I'm content voting him over CD right now. Your priorities are confusing to me. Speaking of which, CD has been shaping up nicely in her recent posts, less interested in lynching her now. The flipflopping looks more neurotic than scummy at this point, though I would prob. recommend her player wait until her thoughts are complete before posting, since that doing otherwise seems to be the source of most of the current attacks on her. I don't agree KS is too bad, though, since he was somewhat vital in getting Silver lynched. However, I do wish he'd post more content that didn't boil down to one-liners. @ Fisherwoman's Daughter: you do realize you can just read the thread, post your thoughts on the players that you have the most notable thoughts about (ie, the people who you think are scummy, and the current hip lynch targets) and it'll take less time but be roughly equal in content to if you made a huge post with totally unnecessary filler content about everybody including your null reads, right? Exile seemingly being content to lurk out the day after posting a defense with no offense makes me content leaving my vote down on him. If you're town, then do something. If you're not town, do something anyway, because chances are it'll still end up making you townier than half of the town players. ATTN resident vig: (1)(2)(3)Make it happen.
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 16:29:13 GMT -5
Post by Miles to Go on Jan 25, 2012 16:29:13 GMT -5
Anyways, I'm guessing that Mountain hasn't been responding because he got subbed out (...it's a little obvious who he was) Ragesubbing because you can't defend yourself would be pretty dumb though, and unfair to the sub. I concur with ToT about CD looking a lot better, though he should try not to focus so much on appeasing other players in future. Or rather, don't just do what you've seen others do ("pulling a clipsey" for example,) do your own thing. ##UnvotePeople I'm fine with lynching(in order of preference): Mountain - Self explanatory. Exile - It bugs me that Exile was coaching CD to form his own opinions and vote based on them when you have yet to do so himself. That coupled with ToT's arguments is making him look pretty shifty. War Between Brothers - My interest in WBB is his shaky case on ToT Day 1 and his claim that Team Skull is a faction, this is the crux of the reason for me being fine lynching him, if he flipped guild, I'd be happy to move on knowing that there are 3 factions. ... Now I know that's not a particularly good reason for lynching him, I just wouldn't complain since it would get us information. Right now, however, I'm more concerned about us actually getting a lynch in and it not being a mad dash like yesterday, so I'd like to hear what the rest of you think.
|
|
|
Day 2
Jan 25, 2012 17:08:17 GMT -5
Post by Mountain on Jan 25, 2012 17:08:17 GMT -5
Sigh. Hi. I'm a new Mountain. I have badminton for the next two hours and I have all of night 1 and day 2 to read over. After that I will read through and try to clear up whatever the reason is the previous me seems super scummy.
Also, I have no idea how much longer phase lasts, but hopefully it doesn't end within the next 4 hours.
|
|