The new MoaM said he hasn't read all of D3 yet.
Also,
I exist! \o/ Scum NK Priority List (with thought processes!):
--- Town
(1. Trail of Tears)
2. War Between Brothers - Exile tried to push this guy as a counterwagon to Tarnished Silver when he could have kept pushing Mountain instead if both Silver and WBB were scum. His logic has been kinda crazy but from my PoV he seems to be most obvtown. The claims about Skull are confirmable information too if a member of it flips.
3. May Queen - Early town read, was at the base of the Silver wagon without switching off after Silver posted, meaning we probably wouldn't have gotten a D1 scum lynch without him starting it. Given that he was positioned on the Exile wagon, too, he seems pretty solidly town to me.
4. Sedna - I doubt scum would tie themself to Silver so blatantly by both sheeping me on the WBB D1 counterwagon, and he was a solid contributor to the Exile wagon as well. There's some weirdness with the switch to MoaM and my gut has felt off about him for a while, but it appeared he intended to return to Exile's wagon by the end of D2 no matter what happened, probably town.
5. Crashing Down - Purely role speculation, but scum already had an extra kill in the form of the flipped JoaT's poisoner. I doubt they have two more. Possible SK given that Katawashoujo voiced suspicion of him before getting shot, but even if he is, he's not one we have to remove to win the game.
--- idk
6. Miles to Go - Has made sense and seemed pro-active all game, but there's no solid information (like VCA or :roles:) pointing to him being town, so no real reason to count him out from being scum at the moment. If it turns out that Exile was bussed by the third scum, I wouldn't be particularly surprised if it was him.
7. Mountain - Words say scum, but claim matches up with what we know and IMO his play is too passive to make sense for lone scum on the verge of losing. Thinking that scum!Mountain would be trying to get townies mislynched right now by starting new wagons instead of just being super passive, since you live for the fight when that's all you've got. Not completely clear, but I'm willing to hold off on this one right now. Also, Duskull was an explorer, not a thief.
8. Fisherman's Boy - Would be in my scumlist if my gut wasn't strongly convinced he's town. His conclusions have seemed to consistently be off when the flips are considered, but being wrong isn't actually a scumtell. I also think the blatant Exile defense is a null tell for reasons I stated earlier today (read the thread, yo). Right now, it feels like his alignment is a total crapshoot, which is very irritating.
9. Measure of a Man - This dude barely exists! Please be posting :words: soon, thanks. Like Fisherwoman's Girl, alignment seems to be a total crapshoot.
--- Voteworthy
10. Call the Names - Sucks about the real life issues, but... yeah, I still think the lack of motivation that has been coming from your player slot all game is scummy. Your past self seemed more passive aggressive than townie aggressive, considering that she took side shots at my posts and the people on the Mountain wagon, but was rather weak-hearted about the May vote she stuck to. Your recent content has been entirely :roles: instead of scumhunting, too. I think it's reasonable to believe scum lurks among the players that have been impossible to read, like you, FB and MoaM, due to the lack of solid interactions with flipped scum we have right now (aside from the ones that involve obvtown getting scum lynched).
Yeahhh I know I told Fishsticks Boy not to do stuff like this but I haven't really talked about anybody but Mountain and CtN today and it's not like I post huge summaries at the same time. I admit I don't have any particularly notable scum reads outside of CtN right now, though that might have something to do with most living players being town, since we already got 2 scum lynches in a row. :T
The combined force of the one-shot vig and our lynches actually leaves us with enough firepower to eliminate everyone outside of the town pile if necessary, though obviously this is no excuse to not actually think about who we're lynching. The problem would be if scum has somehow managed their way into my town list, and I could definitely see Dusknoir being a Godfather, so a Cop probably isn't the most reliable here. Best to just remain wary and keep scumhunting.
If anybody has a role-related clear on a shiftier player and their role isn't important enough to warrant keeping hidden, I think they should go ahead and out it. Additionally, if the Night Bomb that my role mentioned is in a position where they don't think they'll get NKed to use their role, they should go ahead and out themself, since that would nearly confirm them to be telling the truth. Might be less townie since we seem to have a nightvig, but still worth bringing up.